Evaluations of good, better, best can collapse into musical chairs*

by David James

British writer and editor Joseph Pearce has argued, while considering Beethoven’s corpus, that there are two ways to rate music: the “subjective best” and the “objective best”.

He writes: “Clearly the objective best is better than its subjective counterpart. The first has some claim to an intrinsic truth which transcends the perception of it; the other can only claim to be ‘true’ in terms of my own personal and particular perception of it.”

Pearce assert…

Sorry, you don’t have access to this content. Please log in or email [email protected] for help.